2021 DCTF Anonymous TXHSFB Coaching Survey: What UIL football rule would you like to change?

Share or Save for Later

Share on Twitter Share on Facebook Save to Favorites

Dave Campbell's Texas Football surveyed over 360 Texas high school football coaches about various topics, including which UIL football rule they'd like to change.

What UIL football rule would you like to change?
Blindside Blocks
 
blocking below the waist (it should be allowed)
Helmet audio
 
NA
Sideline Warnings
 
Targeting ejections
 
players eligible during school holiday is a bogus rule. no pass, no play!
 
targeting
Onside kick that bounces high
 
Targeting = ejection
NA
 
Cut Blocking removed
 
Cut
none
 
Targeting
automatic ejection for targeting
BLOCKING BELOW THE WAIST
I don’t know
 
NA
Pop-up onside fair catch
 
None
You must play at the high school where you live. transfers within a county or within a UIL district you will sit 2 varsity seasons.
Officials having judgement on what’s targeting and what’s not.
none
Targeting!!! THERE IS NO REPLY TAKE IT OUT!!!
Unsportsmanlike Celebration rules
None
Play Clock after TD's
no pass no play
 
The Cut rule
blindside
Dead periods should go away forever.
restore the old cut block rules
I would like to see the PAPF process be revamped to make it harder for athletes to transfer.
Add some real punishment to the programs that actively recruit players
Chop block
Horsecollar tackle
Bring back the kick return wedge... HA!
Eliminate all blocking below the waist at any time.
Targeting--ejection only if it is 2nd personal foul
Would like them to call offensive lineman downfield on a pass
Video usage during a game
None that come to the top of my head.
5A Division I & II situation - need to not allow schools to "opt up." It's skewing the purpose of having 2 classifications in the first place. If they're not going to make people play where they belong for the sake of convenience, then why have the 2 classifications at all? Just go back to how 6A does it...take the 4 playoff teams and divide into D-1 and D-2 at that time.
The cut block rule I dont like the 5 yard rule You should be able to cut down field
Targeting with expulsion. Officials do not call it at the high school level because they don't want to disqualify a kid. If it were just 15 yards it would be called and kids would be better protected.
Replay on video equipment
hitting defenseless player
Atavus Tackling Certification
Targeting
None
 
Allow side line Hudl.
 
 
Transfer rules
Cut rules
n/a
N/A
Not coaching our kids in 7on7
 
Blocking "defensless" player
The summer S&C rules
Targeting penalty
N/A
Freedom for lineman to cut like old school football
None
Transportation of athletes
Blindside blocks
Bring back cutting downfield
Targeting
Let WR cut again!
More strict on papf's
None
n/a
 
n/a
targeting
cut blocks. Take it out the game!!!
 
none
 
 
Targeting
n/a
Being able to have an opponent during spring football
 
8 hour rule
 
I would like to be able to cut more.
Blindside Blocking
The new overtime rule
Targeting
 
holding should be 5 yards
Get rid of the UIL Portal
Ineligible down field needs to be more than 5yd penalty
Blocking below the waist downfield
Enforce lineman downfield on RPO game.
The new about coaches staying in the box
No rule but do away with the UIL Portal. That things is horrible.
40 Second Clock
The Star Frisco
1st Round Home site
The UIL Portal
Targeting
Blocking below the waist
Use of technology in games
None
 
Allow players to play six quarters per week.
 
N/A
No cut blocking
Cutting down field
None
Transfer (PAPF)
na
Numbers required on shirts pregame.
None
N/A
a penalty when a kid celebrates TD, not crazy, but if you raise your hand its a penaly, stupid
Allowing drones to film the game
The 45 degree chop rule.
Cutting on the permiter
Downfield Cut blocking
I don’t know
Coaching kids during the summer
Allowing video replay on sideline
Eliminate the Targeting ejection. These are HS kids, they will make mistakes
Pass interference
The one that does not allow video to be used as a coaching tool during the game (like Federation rules allow)
 
Can't think of one
Targeting
I don’t know
 
Not having divisions in higher classifications
PLaying JV/9th games on Thursday night.
 
Targeting
 
Nothing stands out at this time
Eliminate all blocks below the waist
None
Cut blocking
 
I would like to change the targeting when a running back lowers his head to run over a defensive player who is attacking near hip near shoulder with running backs hip. I understand targeting, but when does it go into effect on an offensive player leading with his helmet?
 
No more cut blocks period
none
 
New Scrimmage Attire Rule - We wore shorts/knee pads due to the heat
Targeting call carrying an automatic ejection
no sideline replay
I would not do skills in the summer and would allow it outside of the school day for 1 hour
None
 
 
Change targeting back to "spearing"
The targeting rule
 
Girls play girl sports & boys play boy sports
Defenseless Receiver call
 
Allow cutting down field and outside the Tackle box again. There was not near as many injuries and less helmet to helmet collisions
Holding calls on 3rd down Offense only still call it on the defense
 
Cut rule.
targeting
Targeting because there is no replay to confirm
cuts opened back up a little bit
Live Broadcasting
Turn back blocks
 
enforce papf
Acclimation period for spring training. They are already in shape.
 
PAPF rule
Targeting
Blocking below the waist.
N/A
 
The 40 second clock
like to go back to cut blocks any where on the field. Little man is now at a disadvantage.
 
Coaching kids in 7on7
 
Lineman allowed to block downfield on RPOs
 
 
Linemen cutting down field on screens.
Umpires behind LOS , not dodging and calling penalties they can’t really see
Targeting without video proof
NONE
The one I would have like to see changed did get changed and that was the 2 pt conversion after third overtime.
Any rule that I get flagged for.
Targeting
Move 7 on 7 to the spring and outlaw summer 7 on 7. We all coach our players in some version of spring football regardless of classification. Any player playing for a "select" league should lose 1 year of eligibility. This would get the street agents out of our business.
 
If they are enrolled in your school, they can play.
High School coaches not being to coach 7 on 7
Letting schools outsource strength and conditioning…Make those rich schools work like the rest of us…
 
The ability to cut block down field on screen plays
The length of each quater
N/A
Coaches coaching 7 on 7
Targeting call carrying an automatic ejection
Papf
 
Most of the cut block rules
 
Cut blocks
Coaches being able to leave the customary sideline box like they did during COVID last year.
None in particular
Not allowing helmets while going through school and summer sport specific training. I feel like it would improve the safety for the athletes as well as help with the acclimatization.
Coaches are able to coach during 7 on 7
NA
The one where can't block back anymore
Down blocks
Must live with a Guardian/Parent to be eligible for Varsity Athletics.
Special teams
Targeting
none
N/a
Lineman downfield
NA
We have too much access to kids, need to cut back on time allowed with them
kicking kids out of the game for the first targeting penalty
Allow the kids to play when it come to tackling
Overtime
Summer sport specific practice time (eliminate it and give kids and coaches a summer break)
Ejection from a game from targeting / PAPF rules, limit PAPF's to 10 per season per sport
On PAPF's - If a kid never played a UIL sport at their old school (even if they were in Athletics), we should not have to fill out a PAPF. Just my opinion. Need to cut down on paper work in the UIL Portal.
Targeting
No automatic ejection for targeting. 15 yard PF for the 1st, ejection for the 2nd.
Don't have one
Recruiting and transfers are out of control. They need to get more serious about it. They approve way to many that are red flagged.
n/a
Transfer student rule
None
None
Transfer rules, one way or the other. If UIL is going to continue turn a blind eye and knowingly allow all star teams from Houston, Dallas and Austin, then open up transfers and allow all schools to benefit. If not then put an end to all transfers within a certain mile radius and investigate all transfers.
None
Summer workouts and 7 on 7. Get back to less contact time with our kids! It's draining them and coaches. And most don't get paid for all the time
Targeting
targeting
To go back to having 2 a day practices again on consecutive days
over the top ejections...
I'm good with the rules, just want more consistency in which they are governed/followed - both on and off field.
Allow use of video technology during games.
 
 
Uniform dress code (specifically knee pads) Officials are not consistent with it.
None
None
Block below the waist
 
I would like to see coaches be able to go down to 10 yard line on sideline like it was this past year for COVID.
RPO's, blocking down field
NA
Target ejection because no replay to confirm
I don’t like live streaming our games.
N/A
Jersey rule
All Good
N/A
 
 
Bring back down the field cut blocking.
scrimmage another team during spring training
Cut blocking
none
no pass-no play
Transfer rule - PAPF
None
Transfer rules
 
None
Coaches being able to coach 7 on 7.
Cut block
targeting -
Jerseys- enforce it or get rid of it
 
Downfield cut
Cutt blocking by wing backs & cut blocking down field
Games have gotten too long
 
Broadcasting
Transfer rules
 
No televised games!
 
?
 
blocking below the waist
No Complaints
No Cut pass 5 yards
 
None
Targeting disqualification after one foul
 
 
Blind side
N/A
Let us cut block
N/A
 
I would like to have a mini camp for a week instead of doing skills everyday.
Instant replay.
 
N/A
Knee pads (leave em' alone) - Offenses hiding / disguising which WR's are on / off the line. Usually associated with tempo offense.
the lack of consistency of TASO
Cut block down field.
Put back cut blocking--It is taking the little guy out of the game
 
Cut Blocking
Ejection rule, where kids have to sit out the next game.
Targeting
Coaches/players box extended to 20 yard line
N/A
Cutting anywhere on field back to old way
 
Coaches need t be able to coach their teams in 7 on 7.
nA
Cut rule
 
Cutting
 
Letting high school coaches coach their 7 on 7 teams
Ejection rules
Targeting
Would just like more uniform enforcement.
 
Ejections for Targeting
 
I don't feel like it should be a mandatory ejection for targeting or leading with the head for the first offense. I think it should be a penalty and a warning.
 
No cutting outside the Tackle Box
I would like realignment that doesn't make it where all the wealthy schools are the most successful.
Holding----Either call it when they see it or don't call it at all. Too much inconsistency.
Targeting and defenseless player
n/a
 
No change, just enforce offensive pass interference
not everything on computers
No cut blocks past 5 yards from the LOS - when they made the rule change for "safety", they handicapped the undersized offensive lineman. Cutting a defender downfield is no different than that same defender making an open field tackle at the knees on an offensive player.
the new cut rule
 
Blindside blocking near the ball
 

This article is available to our Digital Subscribers.
Click "Subscribe Now" to see a list of subscription offers.
Already a Subscriber? Sign In to access this content.

Sign In
Don't Miss Any Exclusive Coverage!

We've been the Bible of Texas football fans for 61 years. By joining the DCTF family you'll gain access to all of our exclusive content and have our magazines mailed to you!