Money matters
Money matters
2013-08-23 07:30:00

Greg Tepper tackles the question: do richer schools have an advantage in Texas high school football?

 By Greg Tepper
 DCTF Associate Editor
   

If your mother was anything like my mother, inbetween servings of meatloaf and edicts to tidy up your room, you were taught that it’s not polite to talk about money. That’s a private matter, you were told, and was none of your business.

Money is that strange thing that infiltrates everything we do, yet we rarely talk about. And that includes the things we love the most – including high school football.

It’s uncomfortable to talk about the role of money in high school football. With the commercialization of both professional and college football, high school is considered one of the last bastions of purity in a sporting landscape run amok with dollar-driven demagoguery. But to turn a blind eye to money’s role in high school football would be naïve at best and disingenuous at worst.

 Every year, high schools pump more and more money into their football programs. From mega-sized stadiums to jumbo-sized scoreboards to palatial indoor practice facilities to state-of-the-art field surfaces to high-tech equipment to wondrous weight rooms, high school football programs in Texas – especially in affluent areas – are beginning to rival some colleges.

And that’s not even counting the performance camps, personal coaches, training equipment and supplements that many high school athletes enjoy in this era.

On the other side of the coin, schools in poorer communities typically don’t enjoy these types of luxuries. But perhaps more impactful is the time and attention factor – players in wealthy communities can generally focus on athletics more than players in less wealthy communities.

The question is, does it matter how affluent these schools are? Does money give high school teams an advantage – and subsequently, put less affluent schools at a disadvantage?

To study this, we’ll take a look at every 5A and 4A state champion since 2000 – a sample size of 52 champs. With the help of intrepid DCTF intern Courtney Schellin, we searched through the US Census Bureau to find the median household income of each school’s ZIP code area. From there, we compared those median household incomes with the state of Texas’ median household income -- $50,920, in case you were wondering.

Now, is the ZIP code area necessarily completely encompassing of the school’s demographic? It’s hard to say. Some high schools take kids from across multiple ZIP codes; other schools split their own ZIP code with one or two other schools. But I’m confident saying that the median household income of the ZIP code gives at least a ballpark of the school’s demographic makeup – that’s to say, if this indicates that the school is in a poorer area, it’s very unlikely that it is, in fact, in a wealthy area.

The numbers, I have to admit, were a bit staggering.

Of the 52 Class 5A and Class 4A champions since 2000, 37 of them have a median household income at least 14% more than the state as a whole. In other words: more than 71% of the state champions have come from richer-than-average areas.

What’s more: 26 of the state champions – half of them – come from areas with a median household income at least 50% higher than the state average. Even more staggering: nearly one in three state championships in this century has been won by schools that feature a median household income more than twice the state average.

Just 12 state championships out of 52 have been won by schools with what we would consider below-average incomes – that is, at least 10% below the statewide average. And it’s been three years since that happened – Abilene’s 2009 5A Division II title was the last.

In all, state champions since 2000 have averaged a median household income that is 70% higher than the state as a whole.

So, what does it all mean?

First of all, it’s important to note that a school’s financial situation does not guarantee anything. Richer-than-average schools perform poorly; poorer-than-average schools win state championships. There’s not one factor that determines the fate of a football team, including wealth.

That said, the facts are clear: richer-than-average schools are more likely to win a state championship than poorer-than-average schools.

Why is that? I suspect it has to do with many factors, many of which I mentioned above. But more than anything, I don’t think you can underestimate the power of an athlete’s availability to focus on football – spending the summer going to camps as opposed to holding a job, for example.

As I mentioned before, it’s awkward to talk about money in high school football. But in studying the numbers, it’s obvious that in high school football, like everywhere else, money talks.

The complete data set for this study is below.

Year/Class School Median Income % of State Median Income
2012 5A DI Allen 91,638 180%
2012 5A DII Katy 120,111 236%
2012 4A DI Denton Guyer 82,988 163%
2012 4A DII Cedar Park 81,819 161%
2011 5A DI Southlake Carroll 183,656 361%
2011 5A DII Spring Dekaney 50,017 98%
2011 4A DI Lake Travis 121,522 239%
2011 4A DII Aledo 99,147 195%
2010 5A DI Pearland 81,090 159%
2010 5A DII Cibolo Steele 80,171 157%
2010 4A DI Lake Travis 121,522 239%
2010 4A DII Aledo 99,147 195%
2009 5A DI Euless Trinity 57,813 114%
2009 5A DII Abilene 37,356 73%
2009 4A DI Lake Travis 121,522 239%
2009 4A DII Aledo 99,147 195%
2008 5A DI Allen 91,638 180%
2008 5A DII Katy 120,111 236%
2008 4A DI Lake Travis 121,522 239%
2008 4A DII Sulphur Springs 41,730 82%
2007 5A DI Euless Trinity 57,813 114%
2007 5A DII Katy 120,111 236%
2007 4A DI Lamar Consolidated 42,532 84%
2007 4A DII Lake Travis 121,522 239%
2006 5A DI Southlake Carroll 183,656 361%
2006 5A DII Cedar Hill 64,834 127%
2006 4A DI SA Alamo Heights 62,294 122%
2006 4A DII La Marque 45,346 89%
2005 5A DI Euless Trinity 57,813 114%
2005 5A DII Southlake Carroll 183,656 361%
2005 4A DI Highland Park 119,517 235%
2005 4A DII Lewisville Hebron 74,415 146%
2004 5A DI Tyler Lee 41,052 81%
2004 5A DII Southlake Carroll 183,656 361%
2004 4A DI Ennis 45,657 90%
2004 4A DII Kilgore 43,964 86%
2003 5A DI Galena Park North Shore 53,695 105%
2003 5A DII Katy 120,111 236%
2003 4A DI North Crowley 83,774 165%
2003 4A DII La Marque 45,346 89%
2002 5A DI Converse Judson 60,896 120%
2002 5A DII Southlake Carroll 183,656 361%
2002 4A DI Texarkana 58,743 115%
2002 4A DII Denton Ryan 69,279 136%
2001 5A DI Mesquite 48,758 96%
2001 5A DII Lufkin 40,188 79%
2001 4A DI Denton Ryan 69,279 136%
2001 4A DII Ennis 45,657 90%
2000 5A DI Midland Lee 74,947 147%
2000 5A DII Katy 120,111 236%
2000 4A DI Bay City 42,158 83%
2000 4A DII Ennis 45,657 90%
  AVERAGE 86,803 170%
  MEDIAN 77,559 152%
  STATEWIDE 50,920 100%

Greg Tepper is the associate editor of Dave Campbell's Texas Football and TexasFootball.com.

He can be reached via e-mail, via Twitter (@Tepper) and via the DCTF Facebook page.


Please remember that you are responsible for the content you post on texasfootball.com. Any content containing profanity, personal attacks, antisocial behavior, or is otherwise inappropriate will be removed from our website. Users who fail to abide by these guidelines may be permanently banned. The comments/ideas shared in the Facebook commenting system do not reflect the views of Dave Campbell¹s Texas Football.

If you would like to report inappropriate behavior within the Facebook commenting system, please email subservice@texasfootball.com and we will review your request.


Subscribe to DCTF

Forgot Your Password?

Not a subscriber yet?
By registering on TexasFootball.com you'll get instant access to exclusive content and printed magazines. learn more »


Headlines
Special Offer

What is being overheard around the state of Texas

WaterCooler Talk
Well deserved for RG3. First the Heisman and now the cover of DCTF. He's certainly getting all the best awards!Ben — Reading, England
Get your copy of the 2014 Summer Edition of Dave Campbell's Texas Football today! Purchase
2014 Cover