Stiff Arm Stats
Stiff Arm Stats
2012-12-11 08:00:00

Statistically speaking, who had the better Heisman campaign: Johnny Manziel or Robert Griffin III?

 By Greg Tepper
 DCTF Associate Editor
   

Two seasons, two transcendent Texas-bred quarterbacks, two Heismans. Life’s pretty good in the Lone Star State.

In consecutive years, Robert Griffin III and Johnny Manziel came from relative obscurity to win the nation’s most prestigious college football award. And in both case, if I may editorialize, they were the easy choice. Quite simply, they were the most statistically dominant player in the country.

Johnny Manziel set all sorts of A&M and SEC records en route to becoming the first freshman Heisman Trophy winner. Robert Griffin III became Baylor’s all-time leader in basically every statistical category, and put up jaw-dropping numbers that dwarfed his competition.

But how do they stack up against one another? Who had the superior statistical Heisman season?

To study this, we need to isolate a few things. First of all, we’re only taking into account games against FBS opponents. We’re not going to reward Robert Griffin III for beating up on Stephen F. Austin, and we’re not giving Johnny Manziel bonus points for helping to hang a combined 117 points on South Carolina State and Sam Houston State.

Secondly – and longtime readers of TexasFootball.com will remember that this is a pet peeve of mine – we’re using rate stats, not total stats. Yes, Robert Griffin III’s 4,000+ passing yards are neat; he also played (or, at least, so far has played) two more games than Johnny Manziel. He shouldn’t get rewarded for that.

So, how do they stack up, given those caveats? Let’s go to the numbers.

Griffin Category Manziel
71.4 Comp % 67.8
335.7 Pass Y/G 297.8
2.8 Pass TD/G 1.8
10.6 Pass Y/A 8.3
63.5 Att./INT 51.4
51.7 Rush Y/G 100.3
0.8 Rush TD/G 1.5
3.6 Rush Y/A 6.3
387.4 Total Y/G 398.1
3.6 Total TD/G 3.3

Griffin was, pretty clearly, the superior passer, with better numbers on all of the passing statistics. Manziel was, pretty clearly, the superior rusher, with better numbers on all of the rushing statistics. And as far as total impact is concerned, well, they’re about even, with Manziel holding the slight edge on total yards and Griffin holding the slight edge on scoring.

But what about the competition? After all, Manziel plays in the SEC, which has a reputation as the finest defensive league in the nation. Griffin lit up the Big XII, which has a reputation as being a wide-open, devil-may-care defensive league.

And it’s true: not all opponents are created equal. Let’s take a look at their opponents using my favorite nerdy football website (I say that as an endearing term, from one nerd to another), Football Outsiders.

The boys there have a few different metrics for college football, and my favorite among them is the Fremeau Efficiency Index, or FEI. It essentially ranks the efficiency of each unit, adjusted for opponent. You can read all about the nitty-gritty here, but in short: it’s a deep-stat way of ranking both teams and individual units, as opposed to just looking at the number of yards or points they gain or allow.

So, let’s look at the FEI rankings of the defensive units that both Manziel and Griffin faced during their Heisman campaigns, and I’ll be honest, this surprised me:

Manziel Opponents FEI Def. Rank
Florida 1
SMU 75
Arkansas 70
Ole Miss 55
LaTech 114
LSU 12
Auburn 102
Miss. St. 64
Alabama 8
Missouri 54
Avg. Rank 55.5
Median Rank 59.5
Griffin Opponents FEI Def. Rank
TCU 42
Rice 94
Kansas St. 19
Iowa St. 37
Texas A&M 27
Okla. St. 3
Missouri 46
Kansas 96
Oklahoma 12
Texas Tech 116
Texas 9
Washington 103
Avg. Rank 50.3
Median Rank 39.5

Yes, that’s right: Robert Griffin III actually faced slightly better defenses than Johnny Manziel. Manziel faced the best overall defense – Florida, the No. 1 defense in the nation (in his collegiate debut, no less) – but both Griffin and Manziel faced three of the top 12 defenses in the nation. And both faced their share of dogs; Manziel feasted on Louisiana Tech and Auburn, while Griffin got the distinct pleasure of taking on Washington and Texas Tech (though he missed much of the Tech game due to injury).

In the end, though, the difference in defenses is relatively negligible. And beyond that, we want to isolate this even further. How did these two Heisman winners perform against the very best defenses they saw?

So, let’s go one step farther. I isolated the statistics for their games against the five best defenses they faced. For Manziel – No. 1 Florida, No. 8 Alabama, No. 12 LSU, No. 54 Missouri and No. 55 Ole Miss. For Griffin – No. 3 Oklahoma State, No. 9 Texas, No. 12 Oklahoma, No. 19 Kansas State and No. 27 Texas A&M.

Here are the raw stats for each in those games.

Manziel Comp Att Yards TD INT Rush Att. Yards TD
Florida 23 30 173 0 0 17 60 1
Ole Miss 17 26 191 1 2 20 129 1
LSU 29 56 276 0 3 17 27 0
Alabama 24 31 253 2 0 18 92 0
Missouri 32 44 372 3 1 12 67 2
TOP 5 TOTALS 125 187 1265 6 6 84 375 4
Griffin Comp Att Yards TD INT Rush Att. Yards TD
Kansas St. 23 31 338 5 1 12 6 0
Texas A&M 28 40 430 3 1 12 15 0
Okla. St. 33 50 425 1 2 16 27 1
Oklahoma 21 34 479 4 0 18 72 0
Texas 15 22 320 2 1 12 32 2
TOP 5 TOTALS 120 177 1992 15 5 70 152 3

And here are how their rate stats look against the top five defenses they faced.

  VS. 5 Best Defenses
Griffin Category Manziel
67.8% Comp % 66.8%
398.4 Pass Y/G 253.0
3 Pass TD/G 1.2
11.254 Pass Y/A 6.8
35.4 Att./INT 31.2
30.4 Rush Y/G 75.0
0.6 Rush TD/G 0.8
2.1714 Rush Y/A 4.5
428.8 Total Y/G 328.0
3.6 Total TD/G 2.0

More or less, comparatively, they look about the same. Griffin is still the superior passer (a little less accurate against the best defenses, a little more prolific), while Manziel is still the superior rusher.

As the saying goes, if you torture numbers long enough, they’ll tell you whatever you want. Who was the better Heisman Trophy winner? It’s…close. Very, very close. Agonizingly close. And it’s all in the eye of the beholder.

But one thing is for sure, at least in my mind: there’s absolutely no doubt that both Johnny Manziel and Robert Griffin III are worthy of being listed among the all-time greats, with their names etched in football history not just in Texas, but across the country.


Greg Tepper is the associate editor of Dave Campbell's Texas Football and TexasFootball.com.

He can be reached via e-mail, via Twitter (@Tepper) and via the DCTF Facebook page.


Please remember that you are responsible for the content you post on texasfootball.com. Any content containing profanity, personal attacks, antisocial behavior, or is otherwise inappropriate will be removed from our website. Users who fail to abide by these guidelines may be permanently banned. The comments/ideas shared in the Facebook commenting system do not reflect the views of Dave Campbell¹s Texas Football.

If you would like to report inappropriate behavior within the Facebook commenting system, please email subservice@texasfootball.com and we will review your request.


Subscribe to DCTF

Forgot Your Password?

Not a subscriber yet?
By registering on TexasFootball.com you'll get instant access to exclusive content and printed magazines. learn more »


Headlines
Special Offer

What is being overheard around the state of Texas

WaterCooler Talk
I started collecting and reading the DCTF magazines back in the 70’s before I was a teen. I love this magazine and consider it the bible of Texas football.Kurt ,
Get your copy of the 2014 Summer Edition of Dave Campbell's Texas Football today! Purchase
2014 Cover